New York City Inspector General Finds NYPD Facial Recognition Policy Violations, Issues 17 Recommendations

New York City’s Department of Investigation (DOI) has issued 17 recommendations on the NYPD’s use of facial recognition after finding that the department largely complies with the city’s surveillance oversight law but violated its own policy in several instances. The report, from DOI’s Office of the Inspector General for the NYPD (OIG-NYPD), audits the department’s facial recognition policy under the Public Oversight of Surveillance Technology (POST) Act, which requires the NYPD to publish a use policy for each surveillance tool.

OIG-NYPD took up the subject in August 2025 after the Legal Aid Society asked it to investigate alleged violations of the policy. According to NYPD logs, the department’s Facial Identification Section ran about 26,000 facial recognition analyses in 2025. The NYPD uses three products: DataWorks Face Plus and the PhotoManager System from DataWorks Plus, and FaceExpert from IDEMIA Public Security. Searches of juvenile arrest photos require separate approval, and the NYPD said seven were run between November 2025 and January 2026.

The review found that between October 2023 and October 2025 the NYPD approved 98 requests to send facial recognition work to U.S. Customs and Border Protection. Each was approved by the Assistant Commissioner for Intelligence and Counterterrorism, which was not consistent with the policy then in effect. The department did not log such requests before October 2023 and provided no logs of denied requests.

A Facial Identification Section training presentation, prepared for a detectives’ course and outside agencies, showed image enhancement techniques now prohibited by the policy adopted in February 2026. It also described cases in which investigators used publicly available photos of high-profile individuals in place of the probe image, the photo of the unknown person being searched, in violation of the policy. The NYPD said the techniques were never common practice and stopped in 2022; OIG-NYPD found no later material instructing investigators not to use them.

Nine recommendations would update the policy to match the POST Act, starting with naming the three products and listing the photo repositories each one searches. Others call for mandatory supervisory review and blind peer review of every analysis, documented authorization before probe images are edited beyond standard parameters, training on the software for all authorized investigators, periodic recertification and annual audits. Investigators have gained access after a four-day FBI course.

OIG-NYPD’s first POST Act report in 2022 recommended image-editing guidelines and periodic audits. The NYPD rejected both, and the City Council later wrote them into law in 2025.

“While surveillance technology can be an important tool relied on by law enforcement, its use must be accompanied by public transparency, policies, and procedures to limit the risk of misuse and protect civil rights,” DOI Commissioner Nadia I. Shihata said.

Sources: NYC Department of Investigation

–

By the ID Tech Editorial Team