India’s Supreme Court Warns UIDAI of Contempt Over Inaccessible Aadhaar Face Authentication for Blind Users

India’s Supreme Court on Monday warned the central government and the Unique Identification Authority of India (UIDAI) that it could take contempt action if they fail to file a detailed response, with a fixed timeline, on making Aadhaar face authentication independently accessible to blind and low-vision people.

The bench was hearing an application by advocate Amar Jain, which said many visually impaired people still cannot complete Aadhaar face authentication without help. The court said the rights of persons with disabilities cannot be compromised for technological convenience, noting that Aadhaar authentication is essential for welfare benefits, pensions, rations and banking, and that being unable to complete it independently effectively excludes people from those services. It directed the authorities to set out the steps taken, the technology developed to address the problem and a timeline for an accessible solution, and listed the matter for a further hearing.

Jain, who is fully blind, has also challenged the face check now required for subsidized cooking gas. Since October 1, domestic LPG customers must complete Biometric Aadhaar Authentication to book refills at the subsidized, government-regulated price, under a requirement announced by the Ministry of Petroleum and Natural Gas. The court has issued notice to the Centre and other respondents on that plea and sought their responses by December 16.

His lawyers told the court that every channel the ministry prescribes, including self e-KYC on the IndianOil ONE, HelloBPCL and HP PAY apps, depends on Aadhaar face authentication. The user must frame their face on screen, hold the right distance and lighting, and prove liveness, including by blinking in response to visual prompts. Advocate Rahul Bajaj said the IndianOil ONE app shows the instruction “PLEASE BLINK” but gives no audio guidance, haptic cue or screen-reader feedback on whether the attempt is working. A blink-based liveness check also excludes people with facial disfigurement, including acid attack survivors, and conditions affecting eyelid movement, the plea argues.

The petition asks the court to order that no consumer with a disability who cannot complete the check be denied the standard 14.2 kg cylinder or the subsidy until an accessible mode exists, and that a declaration backed by a disability certificate suffice in the meantime. It also seeks an affidavit on audio-guided face authentication, liveness checks beyond blinking, alternative authentication modes, human review of failed attempts with power to override, and a dedicated disability helpline.

Bajaj cited the Supreme Court’s April 30, 2025 judgment that directed alternative ways of verifying liveness beyond blinking and held that digital access is part of the right to life under Article 21, requiring Know Your Customer processes to be accessible.

Sources: The New Indian Express, The Indian Express

–

By the ID Tech Editorial Team