Alabama Opens Age-Verification Rulemaking as Fifth Circuit Lifts Mississippi Block and NetChoice Sues Indiana

Age-verification laws in three U.S. states saw new legal steps this week: Alabama began collecting input for app store rules, a federal appeals court allowed Mississippi to enforce its social media law against major platforms, and the NetChoice trade group sued Indiana.

Alabama Attorney General Steve Marshall issued a Request for Information seeking comments, evidence and data to help his office write age-verification rules for app store providers under the Alabama App Store Accountability Act, Act 2026-59. The law requires app store providers to request and verify their account holders’ age category, either through commercially available methods or through a system that complies with rules the attorney general adopts, and bars app stores and developers from letting minors access apps without parental consent. The Computer & Communications Industry Association has sued to block the law.

The questions cover how to evaluate existing age-verification methods, requirements in other jurisdictions, data retention and how to stop minors from getting around the process. Responses are due by January 8, 2027. “Reasonable and effective age-verification rules start with good information,” Marshall said.

In Mississippi, a unanimous three-judge panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit vacated a second preliminary injunction against the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act, known as HB 1126. The 2024 law requires covered platforms to make commercially reasonable efforts to verify users’ ages and to obtain parental consent before known minors can hold accounts. The district court had blocked it as applied to nine NetChoice member platforms, including Facebook, Instagram, YouTube, X, Reddit and Snapchat.

“Because the district court did not perform the fact-intensive analysis necessary to substantiate why the act is unconstitutional as applied to each member website, and because it did not tailor injunctive relief to each member website, it erred in issuing the second injunction,” Judge Cory T. Wilson wrote for the panel, which sent the case back to the district court. In October, a separate appeals court let Georgia enforce its social media age-verification law.

Mississippi Attorney General Lynn Fitch called the ruling “an important victory in our fight to keep our children safe in the digital age.” Paul Taske, director of the NetChoice Litigation Center, said “nothing in the ruling holds that HB 1126 is constitutional” and that the ruling “is about procedure and paperwork.”

A day earlier, NetChoice filed a complaint in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Indiana challenging the social media provisions of HEA 1408. According to NetChoice, the law requires covered websites to determine the age and Indiana residency of everyone who wants an account and to re-verify users’ ages for up to 10 years. Any user flagged as possibly under 16, including adults, has 30 days to prove their age with parental consent or with “transactional data” such as mortgage, education or employment records, or lose the account.

NetChoice argues the law violates the First Amendment and points to federal court decisions that blocked similar laws in Arkansas, Utah and Louisiana, including a ruling against Arkansas’ social media age-verification law. The group is represented by Paul Clement and Erin Murphy of Clement & Murphy.

Sources: Alabama Attorney General, Courthouse News, Magnolia Tribune, NetChoice

–

By the ID Tech Editorial Team