South Wales Police Figures Show Ethnic Minorities Four Times More Likely to Face Officer-Initiated Face Scans

Ethnic minority people accounted for 24 percent of those selected for officer-initiated facial recognition checks by South Wales Police in 2025, despite making up 7 percent of the population the force serves, according to internal figures obtained by Big Brother Watch under the Freedom of Information Act. The force said the figures “raise concerns about disproportionality” and that it would continue to review its approach.

Officer-initiated facial recognition (OIFR) lets officers photograph a person’s face with a smartphone and run the image through NEC’s NeoFace algorithm to search custody images and other face databases. It is intended to identify suspects, wanted people and missing people who decline to give their details when challenged, as well as people found unconscious, uncommunicative or dead. South Wales Police, which covers Cardiff and Swansea, is one of the first UK forces to use it routinely, and similar systems have been trialed by the Metropolitan Police in London and tested in Liverpool.

The figures show officers initiated scans of 257 adults and 14 children in 2025, including two children under 10. More than half of those scanned were suspected of a crime, unlawfully at large or breaching bail conditions. The next most common reason was a belief that the person posed a risk of harm to themselves or others. About one in 10 scans was for a suspected missing person, and the technology was used to identify a dead person about once a fortnight.

Many scans produced no match, or the person agreed to give their identity. Where a match was made, arrests followed in 48 percent of cases and no further action was taken in a third. By comparison, 11 percent of people arrested in the area are from ethnic minorities.

Last week the police inspectorate warned that innocent people, particularly from ethnic minorities, remain at risk of wrongful arrest if forces treat retrospective facial recognition results as evidence. “This data shows that intrusive biometric tools are being used to disproportionately target minority communities,” said Jake Hurfurt, head of research and investigations at Big Brother Watch. Aliya Mohammed, chief executive of the Cardiff-based anti-discrimination group Race Equality First, said: “If existing biases influence who is stopped and scanned, technology can reinforce and even amplify inequality.”

A South Wales Police spokesperson said the number of OIFR searches “remains relatively small, and the use of the technology is in its infancy,” and that each deployment depends on the circumstances officers face and is subject to supervisory and force-wide scrutiny. The force said its review would include input from independent advisory groups and external scrutiny panels.

Sources: The Guardian

–

By the ID Tech Editorial Team